| Survivor | Tribe | Owner | Age | Occupation | Hometown | Week Eliminated | Votes Against | Paid | |
| Lea "Sarge" Masters | Lopevi, Anita | Amy W | 40 | Drill Sergeant | Columbia, SC | Week 9 | 7 | $10 | |
| John Palyok | Lopevi | Matt W | 31 | Sales Manager | Los Angeles, CA | Week 3 | 5 | $10 | |
| Chris Daugherty | Lopevi, Anita | Patty V | 33 | Highway Construction | South Vienna, OH | 1st Place | 3 | $10 | |
| Brady Finta | Lopevi | Paul K | 33 | FBI Agent/Ex-Military | Huntington Beach, CA | Week 4 | 6 | $10 | |
| Rory Freeman | Lopevi, Yassur, Anita | Dave F | 35 | Housing Case Manager | Des Moines, IA | Week 8 | 14 | ||
| Travis "Bubba" Sampson | Lopevi, Yassur | Erick A | 33 | Loss Prevention | Blountville, TN | Week 5 | 5 | $10 | |
| John Kenney | Lopevi | Scott L | 22 | Model | Los Angeles, CA | Week 7 | 5 | $10 | |
| James "Chad" Crittenden | Lopevi, Anita | Pam D | 35 | Teacher | Oakland, CA | Week 10 | 7 | $10 | |
| Brook Geraghty | Lopevi | Lisa B | 27 | Project Manager | Winthrop, MA | Week 1 | 5 | $10 | |
| Leann Slaby | Yassur, Anita | Julie C | 35 | Research Assistant | Kansasville, WI | Week 11 | 8 | $10 | |
| Twila Tanner | Yassur, Lopevi, Anita | Mark A | 41 | Highway Repair | Marshall, MO | 2nd Place | 6 | $10 | |
| Ami Cusack | Yassur, Anita | Brian P | 31 | Barista/Model | Lakewood, CO | Week 12 | 8 | $10 | |
| Dr. Scout Cloud Lee | Yassur, Anita | Brian K | 59 | Rancher/Entrepreneur | Stillwater, OK | 3rd Place | 3 | $10 | |
| Julie Berry | Yassur, Lopevi, Anita | Andy Z | 23 | Youth Mentor | Gorham, ME | Week 13 | 4 | $10 | |
| Lisa Keiffer | Yassur | Jennifer M | 44 | Real Estate Agent | New Orleans, LA | Week 6 | 4 | $10 | |
| Dolly Neely | Yassur | Jennifer S | 25 | Sheep Farmer | Mercer, PA | Week 2 | 5 | $10 | |
| Mia Galeotalanza | Yassur | Nancy A | 30 | Finance Manager | Toms River, NJ | Week 3 | 5 | $10 | |
| Eliza Orlins | Yassur, Anita | Grace F | 21 | Pre-Law Student | Syracuse, NY | 4th Place | 6 | ||
| 106 | $160 | ||||||||
| $10 Per Person. First Place: $120, Second Place: $60 | |||||||||
| Challenges | Reward | Immunity | |||||||
| Week 1 - 9/16/04 | Yasur | Yasur | |||||||
| Week 2 - 9/23/04 | <None> | Yasur | |||||||
| Week 3 - 9/30/04 | Lopevi | John Kenney & Ami Cusack | |||||||
| Week 4 - 10/7/04 | Yasur | Yasur | |||||||
| Week 5 - 10/14/04 | Lopevi | Lopevi | |||||||
| Week 6 - 10/21/04 | Lopevi | Lopevi | |||||||
| Week 7 - 10/28/04 | Lopevi | Lopevi | |||||||
| Week 8 - 11/4/04 | Lopevi | Lea "Sarge" Masters | |||||||
| Week 9 - 11/11/04 | Leann Slaby | Ami Cusack | |||||||
| Week 10 - 11/18/04 | Ami, Chris, Eliza, Chad | Twila Tanner | |||||||
| Week 11 - 11/25/04 | Eliza Orlins | Ami Cusack | |||||||
| Week 12 - 12/2/04 | Ami, Eliza, Chris | Chris Daugherty | |||||||
| Week 13 - 12/9/04 | Julie ( picks Chris ) | Eliza Orlins | |||||||
| Week 14(1) - 12/12/04 | <None> | Chris Daugherty | |||||||
| Week 14(2) - 12/12/04 | <None> | Chris Daugherty | |||||||
| Jury Member | Voted For | ||||||||
| Lea "Sarge" Masters | Chris Daugherty | ||||||||
| James "Chad" Crittenden | Chris Daugherty | ||||||||
| Leann Slaby | Chris Daugherty | ||||||||
| Ami Cusack | Twila Tanner | ||||||||
| Julie Berry | Chris Daugherty | ||||||||
| Eliza Orlins | Chris Daugherty | ||||||||
| Dr. Scout Cloud Lee | Twila Tanner | ||||||||