| Survivor | Tribe | Owner | Week Eliminated | Votes Against | Paid | Name | Age | Status | Hometown | Occupation | |
| Roger Sexton | Tambaqui / Jacare | Lou T | Week 7 | 11 | $10 | Roger Sexton | 56 | Married | Valencia, CA | Vice President of Estimating | |
| Butch Lockley | Tambaqui / Jacare | Paul K | 4th Place | 5 | $10 | Butch Lockley | 50 | Married | Olney, IL | Middle School Principal | |
| Dave Johnson | Tambaqui / Jacare | Jim H | Week 8 | 8 | $10 | Dave Johnson | 24 | Single | Pasadena, CA | Rocket Scientist | |
| Christy Smith | Tambaqui / Jacare | Nancy A | Week 11 | 9 | $10 | Christy Smith | 24 | Single | Basalt, CO | Children Adventure Guide for the Deaf | |
| Heidi Strobel | Tambaqui / Jacare | Erica K | Week 12 | 3 | Heidi Strobel | 24 | Single | Buffalo, MO | P.E. Teacher | ||
| Jeanne Hebert | Tambaqui | Pam D | Week 5 | 5 | $10 | Jeanne Hebert | 41 | Married | North Attleboro, MA | Director of Marketing | |
| Ryan Aiken | Tambaqui | Lee S | Week 1 | 4 | $10 | Ryan Aiken | 23 | Single | Ellicott City, MD | Model & Actor | |
| Daniel Lue | Tambaqui | Scott L | Week 3 | 7 | Daniel Lue | 27 | Single | Houston, TX | Tax Accountant | ||
| Deena Bennett | Jaburu / Jacare | Jen S | Week 9 | 6 | $10 | Deena Bennett | 35 | Married | Riverside, CA | Deputy District Attorney | |
| Shawna Mitchell | Jaburu | Patty V | Week 6 | 6 | Shawna Mitchell | 23 | Single | Redwood City, CA | Retail Clothing Sales | ||
| Jenna Morasca | Jaburu / Jacare | Lisa B | 1st Place | 3 | $10 | Jenna Morasca | 21 | Single | Pittsburgh, PA | Swimsuit Model | |
| Rob Cesternino | Jaburu / Jacare | Brian P | 3rd Place | 4 | $10 | Rob Cesternino | 24 | Single | Wantagh, NY | Computer Projects Coordinator | |
| Alex Bell | Jaburu / Jacare | Mark A | Week 10 | 6 | $10 | Alex Bell | 32 | Single | Los Angeles, CA | Triathlon Trainer | |
| Matthew Von Ertfelda | Jaburu / Jacare | Erick A | 2nd Place | 6 | $10 | Matthew Von Ertfelda | 33 | Single | Washington, D.C. | Restaurant Designer | |
| Janet Koth | Jaburu | Julie C | Week 2 | 5 | Janet Koth | 47 | Married | Manchester, MO | Travel Agent/Abstinence Counselor | ||
| JoAnna Ward | Jaburu | Jen M | Week 4 | 4 | JoAnna Ward | 31 | Single | Orangeburg, SC | School Guidance Counselor | ||
| 92 | $110 | ||||||||||
| $10 Per Person. First Place: $100, Second Place: $60 | |||||||||||
| Challenges | Reward | Immunity | |||||||||
| Week 1 | None | Jaburu | |||||||||
| Week 2 | Jaburu | Tambaqui | |||||||||
| Week 3 | Jaburu | Jaburu | |||||||||
| Week 4 | Tambaqui | Tambaqui | |||||||||
| Week 5 | Tribe Switch | Jaburu | |||||||||
| Week 6 | Tambaqui | Tambaqui | |||||||||
| Week 7 | None | Deena | |||||||||
| Week 8 | Dave (Picks Deena) | Jenna | |||||||||
| Week 9 | Alex (Picks Jenna) | Matthew | |||||||||
| Week 10 | None | Rob | |||||||||
| Week 11 | Matthew | Jenna (Gives to Heidi) | |||||||||
| Week 12 | Matthew (Picks Rob) | Matthew | |||||||||
| Week 13 - Part 1 | None | Jenna | |||||||||
| Week 13 - Part 2 | None | Jenna | |||||||||
| Jury Member | Voted For | ||||||||||
| Dave Johnson | Jenna Morasca | ||||||||||
| Deena Bennett | Jenna Morasca | ||||||||||
| Alex Bell | Jenna Morasca | ||||||||||
| Christy Smith | Jenna Morasca | ||||||||||
| Heidi Strobel | Jenna Morasca | ||||||||||
| Butch Lockley | Jenna Morasca | ||||||||||
| Rob Cesternino | Matthew Von Ertfelda | ||||||||||