| Survivor | Tribe | Owner | Week Eliminated | Votes Against | Paid | Name | Age | Status | Hometown | Occupation | ||
| Burton Roberts | Drake / Balboa | Pam D | Week 4 / Week 13 | 7 | $10 | Burton Roberts | 31 | Single | San Francisco, CA | Marketing Executive | ||
| Christa Hastie | Drake / Balboa | Brian P | Week 12 | 3 | $10 | Christa Hastie | 24 | Engaged | Los Angeles, CA | Computer Programmer | ||
| Jon Dalton | Drake / Balboa | Julie C | 3rd Place | 7 | Jon Dalton | 29 | Single | Danville, VA | Art Consultant | |||
| Michelle Tesauro | Drake | Lisa B | Week 5 | 6 | $10 | Michelle Tesauro | 22 | Single | Pittstown, NJ | Student | ||
| Rupert Boneham | Drake / Balboa | Patty V | Week 10 | 6 | $10 | Rupert Boneham | 39 | Married | Indianapolis, IN | Troubled Teens Mentor | ||
| Sandra Diaz-Twine | Drake / Balboa | Mark A | 1st Place | $10 | Sandra Diaz-Twine | 29 | Married | Ft. Lewis, WA | Office Assistant | |||
| Shawn Cohen | Drake | Jim H | Week 7 | 5 | $10 | Shawn Cohen | 29 | Single | New York, NY | Advertising Sales | ||
| Trish Dunn | Drake | Scott L | Week 6 | 4 | $10 | Trish Dunn | 42 | Married | Sales Executive | Annapolis, MD | ||
| Andrew M. Savage | Morgan / Balboa | Nancy A | Week 8 | 6 | $10 | Andrew M. Savage | 40 | Married | Chicago, IL | Attorney | ||
| Darrah Johnson | Morgan / Balboa | Jen S | 4th Place | 6 | $10 | Darrah Johnson | 22 | Single | Liberty, MS | Mortician | ||
| Lillian "Lill" Morris | Morgan / Balboa | Lee S | 2nd Place | 6 | $10 | Lillian "Lill" Morris | 51 | Married | Cincinnati, OH | Scout Troop Leader | ||
| Nicole Delma | Morgan | Erick A | Week 1 | 7 | $10 | Nicole Delma | 24 | Single | Hermosa Beach, CA | Massage Therapist | ||
| Osten Taylor | Morgan | Jenn M | Week 7 | 7 | $10 | Osten Taylor | 27 | Single | Boston, MA | Equity Trade Manager | ||
| Ryan Opray | Morgan / Balboa | Phil G | Week 9 | 8 | $10 | Ryan Opray | 31 | Single | Los Gatos, CA | Electrician | ||
| Ryan Shoulders | Morgan | Jennifer R | Week 2 | 6 | $10 | Ryan Shoulders | 23 | Single | Clarksville, TN | Produce Clerk | ||
| Tijuana Bradley | Morgan / Balboa | Paul K | Week 11 | 5 | Tijuana Bradley | 27 | Single | St. Louis, MO | Pharmaceutical Sales | |||
| 89 | $140 | |||||||||||
| $10 Per Person. First Place: $100, Second Place: $60 | ||||||||||||
| Challenges | Reward | Immunity | ||||||||||
| Week 1 | <None> | Drake | ||||||||||
| Week 2 | Drake | Drake | ||||||||||
| Week 3 | Drake | Drake | ||||||||||
| Week 4 | Drake | Morgan | ||||||||||
| Week 5 | Morgan | Morgan | ||||||||||
| Week 6 | Drake | Morgan | ||||||||||
| Week 7 | <None> | <None> | ||||||||||
| Week 8 | <None> | Burton - Gives to Rupert | ||||||||||
| Week 9 | Rupert - Gives to Burton | Rupert Boneham | ||||||||||
| Week 10 | Burton & Lillian | Burton Roberts | ||||||||||
| Week 11 | <None> | Darrah Johnson | ||||||||||
| Week 12 | Jon, Lillian & Darrah | Darrah Johnson | ||||||||||
| Week 13 | Burton - Picks Jon | Darrah Johnson | ||||||||||
| Week 14 - Part 1 | <None> | Outcast Tribe | ||||||||||
| Week 14 - Part 2 | <None> | Lillian "Lill" Morris | ||||||||||
| Jury Member | Voted For | |||||||||||
| Ryan Opray | Sandra Diaz-Twine | |||||||||||
| Rupert Boneham | Sandra Diaz-Twine | |||||||||||
| Tijuana Bradley | Lillian "Lill" Morris | |||||||||||
| Christa Hastie | Sandra Diaz-Twine | |||||||||||
| Burton Roberts | Sandra Diaz-Twine | |||||||||||
| Darrah Johnson | Sandra Diaz-Twine | |||||||||||
| Jon Dalton | Sandra Diaz-Twine | |||||||||||