| Survivor | Tribe | Previous Survivor & Place | Season # | Age | Owner | Week Eliminated | Votes Against | Paid | |
| Alicia Calaway | Chapera, Moga Moga, Chaboga Mogo | Australian Outback - 9th | 2 | 35 | Matt W | Week 12 | 7 | $10 | |
| Amber Brkich | Chapera, Chaboga Mogo | Australian Outback - 6th | 2 | 25 | Julie C | 1st Place | 6 | $10 | |
| Rob Cesternino | Chapera | The Amazon - 3rd | 6 | 25 | Mark A | Week 4 | 5 | $10 | |
| Robert Mariano | Chapera, Moga Moga, Chaboga Mogo | Marquesas - 10th | 4 | 28 | Amy K | 2nd Place | 1 | $10 | |
| Susan Hawk | Chapera | Pulau Tiga - 4th | 1 | 42 | Erick A | Week 6 | 0 | $10 | |
| Tom Buchanan | Chapera, Moga Moga, Chaboga Mogo | Africa - 4th | 3 | 48 | Phil G | Week 14 | 4 | $10 | |
| Ethan Zohn | Saboga, Moga Moga | Africa - Winner | 3 | 30 | Pam D | Week 8 | 6 | $10 | |
| Jenna Lewis | Saboga, Chapera, Chaboga Mogo | Pulau Tiga - 7th | 1 | 26 | Paul K | 3rd Place | 4 | $10 | |
| Jerri Manthey | Saboga, Moga Moga, Chapera | Australian Outback - 8th | 2 | 33 | Scott L | Week 9 | 7 | ||
| Rudy Boesch | Saboga | Pulau Tiga - 3rd | 1 | 76 | Andy Z | Week 2 | 3 | $10 | |
| Rupert Boneham | Saboga, Chapera, Moga Moga, Chaboga Mogo | Pearl Islands - 8th | 7 | 40 | Patty V | 4th Place | 4 | $10 | |
| Tina Wesson | Saboga | Australian Outback - Winner | 2 | 42 | Nancy A | Week 1 | 4 | $10 | |
| Colby Donaldson | Moga Moga | Australian Outback - 2nd | 2 | 29 | Dave F | Week 7 | 4 | $10 | |
| Jenna Morasca | Moga Moga | The Amazon - Winner | 6 | 22 | Brian K | Week 3 | 0 | $10 | |
| Lex Van Den Berghe | Moga Moga, Chapera, Chaboga Mogo | Africa - 3rd | 3 | 40 | Lisa B | Week 10 | 7 | $10 | |
| Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien | Moga Moga, Chapera, Chaboga Mogo | Marquesas - 3rd | 4 | 50 | Jenny M | Week 11 | 6 | $10 | |
| Richard Hatch | Moga Moga | Pulau Tiga - Winner | 1 | 42 | Brian P | Week 5 | 6 | $10 | |
| Shii Ann Huang | Moga Moga, Chapera, Chaboga Mogo | Thailand - 10th | 5 | 30 | Jen S | Week 13 | 5 | $10 | |
| 79 | $170 | ||||||||
| $10 Per Person. First Place: $120, Second Place: $60 | |||||||||
| Challenges | Reward | Immunity | |||||||
| Week 1 - 2/1/04 | <None> | Moga Moga, Chapera | |||||||
| Week 2 - 2/5/04 | Saboga | Chapera, Moga Moga | |||||||
| Week 3 - 2/12/04 | Chapera | <None> (Jenna Morasca Leaves) | |||||||
| Week 4 - 2/19/04 | Chapera | Moga Moga, Saboga | |||||||
| Week 5 - 2/26/04 | Moga Moga (Saboga Dissolved) | Chapera | |||||||
| Week 6 - 3/4/04 | Moga Moga | <None> (Susan Hawk Leaves) | |||||||
| Week 7 - 3/11/04 | Chapera | Chapera | |||||||
| Week 8 - 3/17/04 | Chapera | Chapera | |||||||
| Week 9 - 4/1/04 | <None> | Moga Moga | |||||||
| Week 10 - 4/8/04 | Rupert Boneham | Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien, Robert Mariano | |||||||
| Week 11 - 4/15/04 | Robert M, Jenna L, Amber B, Shii Ann | Robert Mariano | |||||||
| Week 12 - 4/22/04 | Rupert Boneham | Shii Ann Huang | |||||||
| Week 13 - 4/29/04 | Tom Buchanan - Picks Rupert Boneham | Tom Buchanan | |||||||
| Week 14 - 5/6/04 | Robert M picks Amber B | Robert Mariano | |||||||
| Week 15(1) - 5/9/04 | <None> | Amber Brkich | |||||||
| Week 15(2) - 5/9/04 | <None> | Robert Mariano | |||||||
| Jury Member | Voted For | ||||||||
| Lex Van Den Berghe | Amber Brkich | ||||||||
| Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien | Robert Mariano | ||||||||
| Alicia Calaway | Amber Brkich | ||||||||
| Shii Ann Huang | Amber Brkich | ||||||||
| Tom Buchanan | Amber Brkich | ||||||||
| Rupert Boneham | Robert Mariano | ||||||||
| Jenna Lewis | Robert Mariano | ||||||||