| Survivor | Tirbe | Random Selected By | Picked to Win By | Age | Occupation | Hometown | Week Eliminated | Votes Against | Paid | |
| Coby Archa | Koror | Nancy A | 32 | Hairstylist | Athens, TX | Week 9 | 7 | |||
| Williard Smith | Koror | Mark A | 57 | Lawyer | Bellevue, WA | Week 5 | 8 | |||
| Janu Tornell | Koror | Scott L | Andy W, Pam D, Nancy A | 39 | Showgirl | Las Vegas, NV | Week 10 | 1 | ||
| Tom Westman | Koror | Andy Z | Erick A, Phil G, Julie C | 41 | NYC Firefighter | Sayville, NY | 1st Place | |||
| Katie Gallagher | Koror | Phil K | 29 | Advertising Executive | Merced, CA | 2nd Place | 1 | |||
| Caryn Groedel | Koror | Patty V | Andy Z, Diana M, Patty V | 46 | Civil Rights Attorney | Solon, OH | Week 13 | 7 | ||
| Gregg Carey | Koror | Joe D | Matt W | 28 | Business Consultant | Chicago, IL | Week 12 | 4 | ||
| Ian Rosenberger | Koror | Julie C | Amy W | 23 | Dolphin Trainer | Key Largo, FL | 3rd Place | 4 | ||
| Jennifer Lyon | Koror | Jenny M | Jenny M | 32 | Nanny | Encino, CA | 4th Place | 2 | ||
| Ashlee Ashby | Ulong | Erick A | 22 | Student | Easley, SC | Week 2 | 6 | |||
| Bobby Jon Drinkard | Ulong | Pam D | Paul K, Brian P | 27 | Waiter | Santa Monica, CA | Week 8 | 2 | ||
| Angie Jakusz | Ulong | Lisa B | 24 | Bartender | New Orleans, LA | Week 5 | 5 | |||
| Jolanda Jones | Ulong | Brian P | 39 | Lawyer | Houston, TX | Week 1 (2) | 6 | |||
| Stephenie LaGrossa | Ulong, Koror | Phil G | Mark A, Jen S | 25 | Sales Representative | Philadelphia, PA | Week 11 | 8 | ||
| James Miller | Ulong | Paul K | Phil K | 33 | Steel Worker | Mobile, AL | Week 6 | 6 | ||
| Ibrehem Rahman | Ulong | Jen S | Joe D | 27 | Waiter | Birmingham, AL | Week 7 | 3 | ||
| Jeff Wilson | Ulong | Andy W | Scott L | 21 | Personal Trainer | Ventura, CA | Week 3 | 5 | ||
| Kimberly Mullen | Ulong | Amy W | 25 | Graduate Student | Huber Heights, OH | Week 4 | 8 | |||
| Wanda Shirk | <None> | Diana M | Lisa B | 55 | English Teacher | Ulysses, PA | Week 1 (1) | |||
| Jonathan Libby | <None> | Matt W | 23 | Sales & Marketing Exe | Dallas, TX | Week 1 (1) | ||||
| 83 | $0 | |||||||||
| $10 Per Person. Randon Prize: $100, "Pick Em" Prize: $100 | ||||||||||
| Challenges | Reward | Immunity | ||||||||
| Week 1 (1) - 2/17/04 | <None> | Ian Rosenberger, Jolanda Jones | ||||||||
| Week 1 (2) - 2/17/04 | Koror | Koror | ||||||||
| Week 2- 2/24/05 | Ulong | Koror | ||||||||
| Week 3 - 3/3/05 | Ulong | Koror | ||||||||
| Week 4 - 3/10/05 | Koror | Koror | ||||||||
| Week 5 - 3/17/05 | Koror | <None> | ||||||||
| Week 6 - 3/24/05 | Ulong | Koror | ||||||||
| Week 7 - 3/31/05 | Koror | Koror | ||||||||
| Week 8 - 4/7/05 | Koror | Koror | ||||||||
| Week 9- 4/14/05 | <None> | Tom Westman | ||||||||
| Week 10 - 4/21/05 | Tom, Caryn, Jennifer, Ian | Tom Westman | ||||||||
| Week 11 - 4/28/05 | <All> | Ian Rosenberger | ||||||||
| Week 12 - 5/5/05 | Greg - Picks Katie & Jen | Ian Rosenberger | ||||||||
| Week 13 - 5/12/05 | Tom - Picks Ian | Tom Westman | ||||||||
| Week 14(1) - 5/15/05 | <None> | Tom Westman | ||||||||
| Week 14(2) - 5/15/05 | <None> | Tom Westman | ||||||||
| Jury Member | Voted For | |||||||||
| Coby Archa | Katie Gallagher | |||||||||
| Janu Tornell | Tom Westman | |||||||||
| Stephenie LaGrossa | Tom Westman | |||||||||
| Gregg Carey | Tom Westman | |||||||||
| Caryn Groedel | Tom Westman | |||||||||
| Jennifer Lyon | Tom Westman | |||||||||
| Ian Rosenberger | Tom Westman | |||||||||