| Survivor | Tribe | Owner | Week Eliminated | Votes Against | Paid | Name | Age | Hometown | Occupation | ||
| Stephenie LaGrossa | Yaxha, Nakum, Xhakum | Joe D | 2nd Place | 2 | Stephenie LaGrossa | 25 | Tom's River, NJ | Pharmaceutical Sales Rep., Ex-Survivor Contestant | |||
| Jim Lynch | Nakum | Jen S | Week 1 | 8 | Jim Lynch | 63 | Northglenn, CO | Retired Fire Captain | |||
| Brooke Struck | Nakum | Erick A | Week 4 | 5 | Brooke Struck | 26 | Santa Monica, CA | Attorney | |||
| Margaret Bobonich | Nakum | Pam D | Week 6 | 7 | Margaret Bobonich | 43 | Chardon, OH | Family Nurse Practitioner | |||
| Jamie Newton | Yaxha, Nakum, Xhakum | Brian P | Week 10 | 10 | Jamie Newton | 24 | Douglas, GA | Actor/Model | |||
| Judd Sergeant | Nakum, Xhakum | Julie C | Week 12 | 5 | Judd Sergeant | 35 | Ridgefield, NJ | Hotel Doorman in NYC | |||
| Cindy Hall | Nakum, Xhakum | Nancy A | Week 13 | 6 | Cindy Hall | 31 | Naples, FL | Zoo Keeper | |||
| Rafe Judkins | Yaxha, Nakum, Xhakum | Scott L | 3rd Place | 2 | Rafe Judkins | 22 | Pittsburgh, PA | Brown University Student | |||
| Lydia Morales | Yaxha, Nakum, Xhakum | Jenny M | 4th Place | 10 | Lydia Morales | 42 | Lakewood, WA | Fishmonger | |||
| Danielle Boatwright | Nakum, Yaxha, Xhakum | Mark A | 1st Place | 1 | Danielle Boatwright | 30 | Tonganoxie, KS | Radio Talk Show Host, Ford Agency model, actress | |||
| Morgan McDevitt | Yaxha | Andy W | Week 2 | 8 | Morgan McDevitt | 21 | Sullivan, IL | Model/Entertainer | |||
| Brianna Varela | Yaxha | Lisa K | Week 3 | 7 | Brianna Varela | 21 | Edmonds, WA | Retail Sales/Make-up Artist | |||
| Blake Towsley | Nakum, Yaxha | Andy Z | Week 5 | 5 | Blake Towsley | 24 | Dallas, TX | Model, Realtor | |||
| Brian Corridan | Yaxha | Patty V | Week 6 | 7 | Brian Corridan | 22 | New York, NY | Ivy League Student, Tour guide, Research assistant | |||
| Amy O'Hara | Yaxha | John D | Week 7 | 4 | Amy O'Hara | 39 | Revere, MA | Police Sergeant | |||
| Brandon Bellinger | Nakum, Yaxha, Xhakum | Jenny M | Week 8 | 6 | Brandon Bellinger | 22 | Manhattan, KS | Farmer/Rancher | |||
| Bobby Jon Drinkard | Nakum, Yaxha, Xhakum | Paul K | Week 9 | 8 | Bobby Jon Drinkard | 27 | Troy, AL | Model/Waiter, Ex-Survivor Contestant | |||
| Gary Hogeboom | Yaxha, Xhakum | Diana M | Week 11 | 8 | Gary Hogeboom | 47 | Grand Haven, MI | Ex-NFL Quarterback. Real Estate Developer | |||
| 109 | $0 | ||||||||||
| $10 Per Person. First Place: $120, Second Place: $60 | |||||||||||
| Challenges | Reward | Immunity | |||||||||
| Week 1 - 09/15/05 | Nakum | Yaxha | |||||||||
| Week 2 - 09/22/05 | Nakum | Nakum | |||||||||
| Week 3 - 09/29/05 | Nakum | Nakum | |||||||||
| Week 4 - 10/06/05 | <Everyone> | Yaxha | |||||||||
| Week 5 - 10/13/05 | Yaxha | Nakum | |||||||||
| Week 6 - 10/20/05 | Nakum | Rafe Judkins | |||||||||
| Week 7 - 10/27/05 | Yaxha | Nakum | |||||||||
| Week 8 - 11/03/05 | <None> | Gary Hogeboom | |||||||||
| Week 9 - 11/10/05 | Judd, Picks Bobby Jon & Stephanie | Jamie Newton | |||||||||
| Week 10 - 11/17/05 | Danni, Judd, Gary and Stephenie | Rafe Judkins | |||||||||
| Week 11 - 11/24/05 | Cindy, Picks Rafe | Rafe Judkins | |||||||||
| Week 12 - 12/1/05 | <Everyone> | Danielle Boatwright | |||||||||
| Week 13 - 12/8/05 | Cindy, Picks Stephenie | Stephenie LaGrossa | |||||||||
| Week 14 (1) - 12/11/05 | <None> | Rafe Judkins | |||||||||
| Week 14 (2) - 12/11/05 | <None> | Danielle Boatwright | |||||||||
| Jury Member | Voted For | ||||||||||
| Bobby Jon Drinkard | Danielle Boatwright | ||||||||||
| Jamie Newton | Danielle Boatwright | ||||||||||
| Gary Hogeboom | Danielle Boatwright | ||||||||||
| Judd Sergeant | Danielle Boatwright | ||||||||||
| Cindy Hall | Danielle Boatwright | ||||||||||
| Lydia Morales | Danielle Boatwright | ||||||||||
| Rafe Judkins | Stephenie LaGrossa | ||||||||||
